Skip to content
Post Mortem

Biggest cases · September 2020

Düsseldorf hospital: the first ransomware death investigation

A ransomware attack on a German university hospital forced it to turn away emergency patients. A woman sent elsewhere died, and prosecutors opened a death investigation.

HIGHransomwarehealthcaregermanypatient-safety

Details may change as reporting changes. Information comes from the linked sources, and we do not guarantee it is complete or current.

Why it is on the listIt was widely reported as the first death linked to a ransomware attack, and it changed how seriously hospital attacks were taken. The link was never proven.

In plain English

When a hospital's computers fail, it can no longer accept emergencies safely. In September 2020, the university hospital in Düsseldorf was hit by ransomware and told ambulances to go elsewhere.

A 78-year-old woman was taken to a hospital about 32 km away, where treatment started roughly an hour later, and she died. German prosecutors opened an investigation into whether the attack was responsible.

They later closed the death case, saying they could not establish that the attack caused it. The attackers had reportedly meant to hit a university, not a hospital, and German authorities later attributed the attack to a group called DoppelPaymer.

Words used here

Causation
Whether one thing really caused another. In this case, it could not be proven.
Emergency diversion
Sending ambulances to another hospital because yours cannot take them.

What happened

Computers at the hospital were locked by ransomware, and emergency patients were sent to other hospitals.

Prosecutors in Cologne opened a negligent homicide investigation after the woman died in the other hospital. They later closed it because investigators could not establish a causal link between the attack and the death. The investigation into the hack itself continued.

How it unfolded

  1. Mid-September 2020

    The hospital is hit. Emergency patients are diverted.

  2. Following days

    A patient dies after being taken elsewhere. Prosecutors open a death investigation.

  3. Later

    The death case is closed. German authorities attribute the attack to DoppelPaymer.

Who was affected

Patients who needed emergency care in Düsseldorf, and staff who had to work without their systems.

What the response was

  • The hospital diverted emergencies and later restored systems.
  • German police and prosecutors investigated both the attack and the death.

What went wrong

  • A hospital could not safely take emergencies without its computers.
  • A flaw in the hospital's systems was reportedly used to get in.

What worked

  • Staff diverted patients rather than risk care they could not give safely.

What organisations should do differently

  • Treat hospitals and similar services as places where an attack can hurt people, and protect them accordingly.
  • Plan for how you will keep caring for people without your systems.

What you can do today

  • Keep a written list of your medicines, allergies and doctor's number in your wallet or phone.
  • If you run a service people depend on, write down how you would keep going for a day with no computers.

The lesson that still holds

When people's health depends on a system, its failure is a safety problem, not just an IT problem.

Sources

Finished this one?

Add it to What I learned and earn 40 Trust. You can open your list from the badge at the bottom of the page.